The Review Response

As a writer, I believe – in these modern times especially – there is a certain responsibility I must be wary of. Nay, have it become a part of my thinking. That is to do better when it comes to my writing. To be better. Not only for myself but for my readers as well.

But at the same time, I’m not just including myself here, I’m including all writers. And as such, the topic of today’s discussion is responding to those dreaded reviews. Dun, dun, dun!

As an author, one thing must become abundantly clear. Once you publish a story/book it is out of your hands and in the public domain. You are responsible for what you have written, but you are not responsible for other people’s opinions. But, and here’s the kicker, YOU are also responsible as to how you react to reviews.

The golden rule is DON’T.



Don’t ever respond to a review unless you have been invited to do so (by the reviewer). An example of that would be: “Hey, I really liked this book, will there be a sequel (author’s name)?” On every other occasion don’t respond to any review, 5 star, 3 star, or 1 star. EVER! Don’t even ‘like’ a review. It shows how insecure you are. Trust me. It does.

And especially DON’T go on social media to complain about readers who gave you a low rating. That’s just a no no. A big bloody NO NO! You will be automatically placed on a ‘do not read’ list in places like Goodreads. And for an indie author (if that’s who you are) that can hurt sales big time! And I’ve been an indie author, and sales are hard enough to come by as it is. Shooting yourself in the foot will make it worst. Again, trust me on that.

There are so many instances of this sort of thing happening where authors respond to reviews, but I want to draw attention to one author (with 20K + followers on Twitter) who decided it was a good idea to bitch about a 3 star review she got for book 1 or her series of 3. She rallied her followers to basically bash this reader/reviewer for not ‘reading the other two books to get what she wrote’. I mean, seriously? And it was a 3 star review (which according to Goodreads, translates as ‘I liked it’) Imagine if this author got a 1 or 2 star review. Yikes!

First, the privilege shown in those tweets was unbelievable (remember when I spoke about doing better, being better?). She cried victim and blamed the reader THE READER for not ‘getting’ her work. Suffice it to say, this author was called out for what this all was and has now taken a break (gone on hiatus). Yeah. You got caught, and now you have to try and dig your way out of the hole you created. This was really an appalling example of an author behaving badly towards their readers. They are on my ‘do not read’ list too.

Listen, please. Not everyone is going to get your work. But many people will. Take the good with the bad. Learn from reviews if they give good advice. If not. Don’t worry about them. Through the years I’ve had some reviews that have been terrible and some that have made me cry with how wonderful they are. It’s all part of being a writer. And if you don’t want people to review your work (as is their right) then don’t publish. Keep those stories on your hard-drive. Or better yet, just go on LuLu and publish a POD copy for yourself and a few friends. That way you have a story out there but not to the public.

The other thing to remember here is reviews are for the readers, not for the authors. An example of this is to search up your favourite author on Goodreads (or similar site) and see the reviews they got for one of your favourite books of theirs. There’s a mix, isn’t there? Some 1 star and terrible, others glowing. It’s all part of being a writer, getting reviews. But it’s the end process. The part you have no control over.

So just write those stores. Improve your craft and move on to the next one. I don’t even read reviews of my work any longer. Sure, sometimes a friend may point a good one out, but other than that, I don’t. Remember, tweets or posts, even deleted, are remembered by those you’ve offended.

So if you bag reviewers you will be remembered as well…and not in a good way.

King of Thorns

I enjoyed the second book of the Broken Empire trilogy, “King of Thorns” a lot. As far as middle books go, anyway. The final book, “Emperor of Thorns” is next up on my reading list. I’m also really enjoying anti-hero Jorg and his journey as he struggles for power and to reclaim himself, his title, after he lost his mother and brother and his father disowned him. It all sounds noble doesn’t it? Trust me, Jorg is a cheat, a liar, and will do anything, including kill thousands upon thousands, to reach his goal: emperor of the world. This is grimdark fantasy. There is blood on almost every page. Can’t wait to read the last book in the series.

Now. Here’s a map. Look familiar? It’s what Europe and surrounds will look like years after a nuclear winter, and the seas have risen and fallen. Unfortunately, it looks like the UK is worse for wear after such times.

And of course, after that, I’ve got to post some art work (as is usual with my reviews that aren’t reviews) Here is the cover for the book for those folks in Georgia (the country against the Black Sea, not the US state). Love it!


When you create, be that writing, painting, crafting, scrapbooking, crocheting, or whatever, do you listen to music?

I do. I like to mainly listen to instrumental stuff, but sometimes not. I think, for me, music blocks out other distractions. But that’s me. How about you?

The Benefit of Readers

A reader is a valuable thing. And I just don’t mean the reader of the end product, the book on ‘the shelf’ (virtual or otherwise). I’m talking about the readers we have before publication.

There are many type of readers, so let me explain.

Alpha Reader: This is the person who gets to read your work from the very beginning, sometimes chapter by chapter as you pen them. They are the encouragement. The ones who will guide and gently suggest anything obvious that could cause problems later on. I have a fantastic alpha reader who I send each chapter I do as I finish it. Some of the things they have pointed out has been invaluable and saved me a lot of heartache later on.

Beta Reader: This is the person (or many people) who get to read your completed tome in its entirety before any editor or other professional sees the work (and there can be many of those). The beta reader is often asked what to look for in a work, as we all know our weaknesses in our own work. For example: “Can you let me know where I ramble?” or “Are the characters grabbing you?” Things like that. But of course things can go into much more detail. Some beta readers like to correct grammar/punctuation, while others will do a line by line edit. I’ve had a beta sent me extensive notes, all welcome of course. But generally beta readers look for global things that can bog down a story. Whatever beta reader/s you have, they are all valuable. But remember, they are offering their opinion. You are within your rights to agree or not. That’s how it works.

Critique Partner: I think of these people as both alpha and beta readers and can be engaged at any time of the writing process. I’ve done chapter swaps with plenty of writers as we progress through our respective works. I’ve done complete story swaps too. Although, usually alpha and beta readers are not writers, they are purely great readers. With a critique partner they are usually a fellow writer who will offer a different insight to what a reader can. Sometimes a reader can’t pin-point what is wrong with a story but knows there’s something wrong. A critique partner may be able to do this because of their perspective and closeness to the writing process. Eg: the plot is choppy, the character arc isn’t complete, or there is too much detail/not enough etc etc which isn’t letting the reader immerse into the story.

Anyway, I use all three in my writings. I also send my work to a trusted friend who is an editor as well. As such, my writing has improved so much I don’t recognise my earlier works any more. A good feeling.

The Write Balance

Balance is a good thing. It’s not easy to achieve, in fact it’s one of the most difficult things to do in this day and age. If one is a writer, then obtaining some sort of work/life/writing balance can be very difficult.

As things return to some sort of normality here (one hopes) finding balance is even more difficult. But the most difficult thing of all has been self care and how to balance it. I haven’t been very good at that lately. As a result, I’ve suffered. Being isolated and unable to contact the people I usually spend time with has been the greatest loss I’ve experienced in my life.

I have also felt the worst I’ve felt in my life and my physical health has been suffering as a result. I’m turning the corner to improving the situation, but it’s going to be a long road. I’m on medication now too (which my body is still trying to get used to).

But without my writing I think I would have been in a worse situation than I am in now. My writing gives me something to get up for each morning. That in itself is worth everything. So, as restrictions ease, let’s hope I can keep positive and move forward. Let’s hope things for me get back to what they were soon. I know things will be different. But not being isolated will mean I can achieve a better balance. That’s the hope.

Prince of Thorns

To be fair, I know my reviews have been scantly clad as just me wanting to share the books I’ve enjoyed and not really saying anything else. My reviews have lacked a review, as it were. And that’s the way it’s going to stay.

I will say that Prince of Thorns was good. Very good. We follow the story from 10 year old Jorg and go from there (by the end of the book he’s 15). It’s the first in a trilogy and I can’t wait to get stuck into the next one. It’s grimdark. Bloody. And very delicious. The words and language Lawrence uses are exciting and fresh and I loved the writer’s style.

I will also say the books we read do have a lot to do with the books we’ve read before it. I read the phenomenal series “The Demon Cycle” by Peter V. Brett, then I read another book which, unfortunately turned out to be rubbish (for me). Therefore, by the time I came to read this book, I was hoping for something good. And it delivered. I’m sure if I’d read this after the Demon Cycle books, I may not have been impressed. But who knows? Or perhaps this book was one I needed after the rubbish book?

I want to share a piece of fanart of the book with you. Hey, you know you’ve made it as an author when people start going fan art, right? The depiction of Jorg is just how I imagined him, sly and sneaky looking. A cunning boy with more to his name than meets the eye. Which, of course, he is. Here he is meeting Jane and Gorgoth under the mountain that holds a nuclear experiment within a massive bunker (the world of Prince of Thorns takes place eons after a nuclear war and the people before them were known as the Builders. Some of their technology remains). Some people’s of the land have been affected by radiation. Jane (the girl depicted) is one of them.

Artwork is by Lauren Newburg.

I’ve Started Again!

I’ve started writing again! And boy, did I plant those words down for my latest wip! I think I’ve done 4 chapters in a whirlwind of muse rage! It was awesome. The new work is a sequel to “Immortal Whispers” and is so far proving to be darker. I’m loving it.

I think what I’m writing will be a trilogy:

“Immortal Whispers”

“Mortal Screaming”

“Godly Rage”

I think that’s what I’ll call them. They may even be more than three books. My main character Hereward has so much to tell. So much…

The Language of Promotion

When we pick up a book, aside from the cover itself, what can attract us is the ‘elevator pitch’ for said book. Most times this is a sentence written by another author (usually famous and a big name in the same genre of the book) or from the publisher themselves. It can even be a line from a review (usually by Kirkus Reviews or someone similar). This sentence tries to entice you in as little words as possible to buy it (or not, in some cases).

The thing is, I believe a lot of time this elevator pitch is code. Sort of like how real estate agents use their codes to sell houses. “A fixer-upper” or “renovator’s delight” is code for something run down and unliveable next to a swamp or built on a graveyard. While, “Close to all amenities” means you’re going to be living in a crowded urban jungle with neighbours banging against the walls when they copulate or argue…or both at the same time.

So what are some examples of “book promo code” then?

  1. Densely written masterpiece” is code for the writing is so stodgy and laden with metaphors and descriptions, that you’ll need a respirator to get through the first 50 pages. If you last that long.
  2. My new favourite author” is basically saying the reviewer probably had a beer at the pub with the author and thought they were okay. Probably has nothing to do with the contents of the book–unless a packet of crisps was also included with the beers. Then it may reflect the work. It’s a guess really as to what this actually means.
  3. A stunning story full of wonder” is definitely code for the person who really hated this book and could only think of a cliché to describe it because no doubt they were paid to do so and had to come up with something. Anything.
  4. And finally, one of my favourites: “A ground-breaking, genre busting marvel” or words to that effect. This is basically code for “I have no idea what the fuck I read but maybe you’ll have better luck than me making sense of it.”

You get the idea. There are so many, many more. Then again, like all marketing – publishing included – the publisher is trying to sell the sizzle not the steak. I get that. Which is why I don’t take much stock in elevator pitches. I actually find books without any ‘expectation’ imprinted onto me more enjoyable than those that do. But that’s me.

I hope you enjoyed my little tongue-in-cheek post today.

It Has Ended…and Begun

I’m finally done with my latest WIP (work in progress). Like a boy having defeated a terrible monster, I’m done with it. Slayed it. I’ve read it a million times (exaggerated I know, but that’s what it feels like) and my eyes can’t bleed any more. Nor my fingers. I’ve sent it off to my editing mentor and dear friend to now give them the headache of my words and the pain they will inflict upon them! Us writers are savages, aren’t we?

But I have to say, this was the most I’ve ever taken on when it came to my writing. I really challenged myself and tried to do something a little different without it being too far out. I came to love the characters and can’t wait to get into their heads again and write more of their adventures. I also created a whole new world with its own rules. I loved doing it.

But sending it off for editing is just the next step on a long, long road. I promised myself I would do the synopsis this week but didn’t get anywhere near it. I had my boss monster to slay. I wasn’t happy with a few things, but that’s all changed now. I’m happier…note I said happier, not happy. Is a writer ever happy? Now I can tackle a new monster, the synopsis.

Let the battle begin again…

The Core (Demon Cycle)

I know I’m late to the party when it came to reading these books. The last of the series, book 5 The Core, was released in 2017. But hey. I got there. And I’m glad I did. These books swept me away. I loved them. Sure, there were spots where things slowed and certain plot points caused me to pause, but for an overall extravaganza of fantasy these books really hit the spot.

The Demon Cycle is:

The Warded/Painted man

The Desert Spear

The Daylight War

The Skull Throne

The Core

There are also shorter ‘novella’ type books as well to enhance and add to the story lines. So far:

The Great Bazaar and Brayan’s Gold

Messengers Legacy


So there’s plenty of words to get into if you want to start reading this amazing fantasy series. It’s well worth it. I flew through the pages even though each book weighs in at around 800 pages per book (not including the novellas).

Again, like the cover for The Skull Throne, the artwork for The Core was amazing. The demon featuring on it was an actual model, created by Millennium FX

This is then used on the cover, once again done by Larry Rostant

I have to say, there was one character’s death that devastated me in this series. There was another death that seemed senseless and without reason and didn’t even show how it happened, only the result. A bit disappointing.

Other than that, the story was amazing and the world building was superb. I simply loved it. Now I’m finished, there is certainly a hole left where the characters lived while I was reading about them.

Highly recommended.